Alan Blumlein

In 1931 Alan Blumlein applied for a patent on what we now call stereo sound. He described techniques for creating the auditory illusion of placement and depth using two (or more) channels of recorded and reproduced sound. As part of this patent application he described an array of two bidirectional mics in a coincident X/Y arrangement that we today call a Blumlein array:

Two bidirectional or figure 8 mics in a coincident XY

In the same document he described the Mid-Side mic arrangement. Rather than a crossed pair of mics at 45 degrees to the source, the Mid-Side array has the Mid mic pointing directly at the source and the Side mic at right angles to the source. The Mid mic can be any pattern but the Side mic must be a bidirectional or figure-8 mic.

Two bidirectional or figure 8 mics in Mid-Side

Mid-Side Recording

This article from emusician.com discusses the technical details of Mid-Side recording in some depth. Note that the use of different patterns for the Mid mic gives different results after decoding.

When I record in Mid-Side using my home recording chain it’s startling to see the difference in the levels of the Mid and Side channels. With both channels set to the same gain the Side channel barely shows any signal.

Decoding the Mid and Side channels to Left and Right is easy in a multitrack recording program. Simply place the Mid channel on one track panned to the center. Place the Side channel on a track panned hard left. Then place a copy of the Side channel inverted in polarity on a track panned hard right. When you mix the three tracks down you’ll have two stereo tracks.

Here’s a video I made demonstrating Mid-Side and Blumlein arrays with some demonstrations of the stereo field.

There are a few ? ? ? problems with the video, please accept my apologies. The bubble wrap stereo demo is funny (to me anyway), but the clipping caused by the amazingly loud pops wrecked the stereo field. Listen to the incidental noises for a better idea of how these recording techniques work. And the distortion is not there in the my recording, it was introduced by the YouTube compression process.

Mid-Side and the H4n

I also missed several opportunities to actually address some details of the H4n. For instance, the level metering shows levels after the signal is decoded. I think there’s a good chance of clipping the Mid mic and not seeing it in the decoded signal.

When setting up the Mid-Side connections on the H4n, notice that there’s a menu selection to identify which channel is the Mid and which is the Side.

Let me wrap up by mentioning that I sent my H4n back to the seller. I think it’s a pretty interesting recorder, but for my regular uses the H2 does at least as good a job. When I want to do more serious recording I just turn on my home studio system. I’m looking forward to continued progress in these handheld recorders, though. I just can’t resist the idea of a world class recording chain in my pocket.